Subject: »General Questions

So I believe talent is unchangeable in that it’s fixed when they enter the youth school. However, a higher youth coach means that junior improves faster and comes out at a higher level and with more higher skills.

Basically the true talent is fixed, the estimated talent most refer to isn’t.

talent is fixed when they enter the youth school. However, a higher youth coach means that junior improves faster and comes out at a higher level and with higher skills.

exactly

is it really true that with junior games the coach estimates better?

should i play games then?

I do

it's a small advantage, but I like the better estimation for my decision which junior I keep in my own training

and school graphs are much clearer for me than training graphs

So to get clear.

Juniors talent is already established once they get in
Better trainers get to estimate junior talent and level close to reality
If i play junior matches my coach has more chance to get talent and level estimation
Estimation is junior level is +/- 2.5 with magical and should be bigger with worst coach
Junior level and talent is really established when they join and train in main team

I don't think it matters if you win by walkover. The coach estimation is done during the training sessions in preparation for the match ahead, and not during the match itself. That's how it should be at least.

Otherwise, if you have 20 youngsters, and only 11 can play, those who didn't play don't get the same estimation as the rest who played? Wouldn't make sense.

"Juniors talent is already established once they get in"

Kind of. The best way to explain it is to think of it as Potential Talent

So a player has a talent of 3, but it's only with an Unearthly coach that you'll get 100% of that talent.
The potential talent is the same
The actual talent depends on the junior coach

"Better trainers get to estimate junior talent and level close to reality"

Yes

"If i play junior matches my coach has more chance to get talent and level estimation"

Yes

"Estimation is junior level is +/- 2.5 with magical and should be bigger with worst coach"

The estimation is debateable but yes, better coaches get better estimation

"Junior level and talent is really established when they join and train in main team"

The talent is already established, it's just not an estimation anymore.
(edited)

Thanks.

Talent doesnt change.
But juniors improve level faster and have better estimation with better coaches.

Great

I was told it does, it's the only reason I bother keeping 11 kids in my school.

No. Players dont improve more in junior matches

Yeah I didn't think they did.

Yep, my mistake.

Thanks, yeah that makes more sense to me too.

How is it then?

He played regularly Junior League matches:

> Youth Talent Calculator

He came out as:

tragic [0] stamina hopeless [1] keeper
hopeless [1] pace average [5] defender
weak [4] technique average [5] playmaker
average [5] passing tragic [0] striker

Magical junior coach.

My question is: Wtf?

And he is not only one! I have at least 2 more with /\/\/\ graphs after almost linear progression:

> Youth Talent Calculator

> Youth Talent Calculator


Junior school is really messed up... :(
(edited)