Subpage under development, new version coming soon!
Topic closed!!!
Subject: »GK substitutions no limit?
- 1
clarom to
All
what do you think about theses substitutions?
4 GK was used in the match to day
that's crazy and for me this is a big bug
https://sokker.org/comment?matchID=41653775
4 GK was used in the match to day
that's crazy and for me this is a big bug
https://sokker.org/comment?matchID=41653775
may be you do not know football rules!
there are only two GK places in the line up, because you can only use one subsitute GK
there are only two GK places in the line up, because you can only use one subsitute GK
that's not true, for example in Italy teams always have at least 3 GKs
also in European cups teams have 3 goalkeepers
also there is no real limit to that, since even a field player can enter the goal and play as goalkeeper and a goalkeeper can enter the pitch and play as a normal field player
it just doesn't make sense to have more than 2-3 GKs in a lineup especially as teams usually have 2-3 senior goalkeepers in their roster
(edited)
also in European cups teams have 3 goalkeepers
also there is no real limit to that, since even a field player can enter the goal and play as goalkeeper and a goalkeeper can enter the pitch and play as a normal field player
it just doesn't make sense to have more than 2-3 GKs in a lineup especially as teams usually have 2-3 senior goalkeepers in their roster
(edited)
if a file player take a Gk place, this is because no other Gk is available, because the Gk is mandatory in the field
so sokker is not ok with the rules, I have often see match without GK for one team ( after injury or other) and that must be modified.
so sokker is not ok with the rules, I have often see match without GK for one team ( after injury or other) and that must be modified.
no, there is no rule about that, when there is a red card for GK you don't have to enter the sub GK, you can just use a field player
and you can use 3 or 4 GKs in a game if you want
please show me the exact rule from the law of game that is broken here
the Gk is mandatory in the field
yes he is and yes that's a bug here
it's not important though because GKs don't get red cards in this game so you only need to have someone on bench for injury
and that's not why you opened this topic so I don't understand why you bring that up now
and you can use 3 or 4 GKs in a game if you want
please show me the exact rule from the law of game that is broken here
the Gk is mandatory in the field
yes he is and yes that's a bug here
it's not important though because GKs don't get red cards in this game so you only need to have someone on bench for injury
and that's not why you opened this topic so I don't understand why you bring that up now
IFAB Laws of the game:
3.4 Changing the goalkeeper
Any of the players may change places with the goalkeeper if:
the referee is informed before the change is made
the change is made during a stoppage in play
3.4 Changing the goalkeeper
Any of the players may change places with the goalkeeper if:
the referee is informed before the change is made
the change is made during a stoppage in play
This reminds me that in 1996, Molina, a Spanish GK, made his debut in the NT playing as a left wing :P
https://futbolretro.es/en/molina-debuta-con-la-seleccion-espanola/
https://futbolretro.es/en/molina-debuta-con-la-seleccion-espanola/
ok , i'm wrong, for the number of substitution ( nobody is perfect)
as a team cannot play without GK, when all substitutions has been made a field player take the GK role.
so I can close this subject
(edited)
as a team cannot play without GK, when all substitutions has been made a field player take the GK role.
so I can close this subject
(edited)
- 1