Subject: »[V] DEF Valuations

Florin Pintilie, age: 20
value: 72 250 €, wage: 1 450 €
club: Butseuit de Lleida, country: România
tragic form, average tactical discipline
bookings:

average stamina, hopeless keeper
solid pace, formidable defender
hopeless technique, tragic playmaker
unsatisfactory passing, poor striker

Florin Pintilie
500k-->600k euro

Well, I allready said I think it's a good idea. The other valuation topics are very confusing for people, I think that's the reason why nobody valuates first...they just assume that they don't have to. It's wrong to assume, but can you blame them? It's a game for fun, not the cold hard world...

Therefore I think it's either all topics like this (much work for you guys in first place, but after a while it will be okay (I hope), or go on the way we do now with the other topics.

thanks finally somebody giving feedback :) It just took ... 2 weeks? :)

there was people giving feedback. maybe you don´t remember.
agree with kasim. all val topics should be like this one.

I just wonder who the blind man is. Me or you? I just had a look onto the page where the last feedback was given on the valuation issue. I had to scroll back to page 5!

And Yes, I do remember that discussion as I was part of it.

maybe i misunderstood your words. so you meant, that nobody gave feedback for 2 weeks? this "finally" you wrote made me think, that nobody gave feedback;-)
anyhow i think that discussion is offtopic here, but it has to be discussed somewhere.

i would agree, that those "new" rules should be introduced in all val-topics.

"finally" means that this is first feedback with positive opinion :)))

that is not true. Read the posts at the beginning. The finally was becaus Mr G and me were asking for opinions since2 or 3 weeks and nobody bothered to do so.

What's this incredible junior worth?

Aarne Hietapakka, age: 18
value: 128 500 €, wage: 1 650 €
club: hoocee, country: Suomi
very good form, tragic tactical discipline

poor stamina, unsatisfactory keeper
very good pace, very good defender
solid technique, poor playmaker
very good passing, weak striker

talent 3,75
magical coach

2mil €

this one is a monster. he might also do well as a def mid. if you find the right buyer he may bring you 1.5M to 2M €.

Renzo Agurto, age: 25


formidable stamina, tragic keeper
solid pace, very good defender
very good technique, solid playmaker
weak passing, very good striker

Renzo Agurto

800k --> 1million euro

Eddie Turner, age: 22
value: 373 000 €, wage: 5 325 €
club: Orange Minze, country: Scotland
solid form, very good tactical discipline
bookings:

formidable stamina, tragic keeper
average pace, magical defender
weak technique, good playmaker
average passing, poor striker


Nelson White, age: 23
value: 246 750 €, wage: 2 400 €
club: Orange Minze, country: USA
divine form, very good tactical discipline
bookings:

solid stamina, tragic keeper
good pace, outstanding defender
average technique, adequate playmaker
excellent passing, average striker

and these two guys ?

thx